Backstory: The "orphaned" book

 So did you like the movie?
Now, back to the backstory of The You I Never Knew. This series of posts started out as a reply to an e-mail from a fellow writer. By this point in our saga, the book has been written, sold and edited. Now it’s supposed to be published and become a bestseller, right?
Not so fast. One thing that happened to this book is it became “orphaned,” meaning the editor who acquired it moved on while the book was in production. It’s not a total disaster, but it’s usually not the best news for a book, either. Another editor adopts the project, and it’s a bit like she’s getting a foster child she didn’t ask for. In this case, it turned out to be a mixed blessing. They were right in the middle of designing the cover, and it looked like this:

cover never used on the you i never knew
the art i never used on the you i never knew

literary collection of stories

Now, this is not a terrible cover. It’s a fine piece of original art and the design and layout are reminiscent of a Nicholas Sparks cover, so those are pluses. It also looks a bit like Annie Proulx’s Close Range. But does this mean the cover is right for this book? Probably not. First of all, this would be a paperback original, not a hardcover book, so the art needs to “pop” on the shelf in order to stand out. The colors of this cover are muted and the mood is chilly. It might work on a hardcover jacket, but it doesn’t look instantly warm and inviting, like a “feel-good” novel.
So the acquiring editor had left and the new one came into the middle of cover design, knowing nothing about me or the book. There was a bright spot, though. The new editor was the extremely smart Maggie Crawford. This is the kind of foster mother the book needed–an experienced editor who understood the market for this book. She’d worked with many bestselling authors and had a fine eye for marketing women’s fiction. She took on the cover art issue with aplomb, and came up with this.
Book Cover
making the book look like a bestseller

It’s one of the least-relevant yet most commercial covers I’ve ever had. Here’s my analysis: At the time, I was not a name-brand author. Yet splashing my name on the cover in huge letters gave the illusion that this was a big book by a big author. The lettering itself–big, graceful block lettering–was reminiscent of the font used for blockbuster author Sandra Brown. 22 Indigo PlaceOr for bestseller Marcia Muller: Cover Image And of course, it capitalizes on the galloping popularity of the biggest novel of the ’90s, The Horse Whisperer. Cover Image   
So I’m back on track, right? My new editor rescued the novel from obscurity and now all I’d need to do is kick back and let the sales roll in. Oh, and I’d be working with Maggie on the next book, brainstorming the plot and building on the success of The You I Never Knew. Right? Right?
NOT.
Tune in tomorrow for a continuation of the tour through Big Business Publishing….
(stay with me–like my books, this has a happy ending…)

Share this post

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on print
Share on email

0 Responses

  1. Haven’t seen the movie yet, but want to soon. The new cover is so much more eye-catching. Great choice by your editor. Looking forward to reading that one.

  2. Haven’t seen the movie yet, but want to soon. The new cover is so much more eye-catching. Great choice by your editor. Looking forward to reading that one.

  3. I just discovered your blog, and since I’m also a novelist AND I adored the
    grand silliness of Mamma Mia!, I thought I’d say hello. I just blogged on
    my blog about Randy Pausch, in case you’re interested.

    I’ll check back in again!

  4. I just discovered your blog, and since I’m also a novelist AND I adored the
    grand silliness of Mamma Mia!, I thought I’d say hello. I just blogged on
    my blog about Randy Pausch, in case you’re interested.
    I’ll check back in again!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stay In Touch

Be the first to know all the 
updates from Susan